Buffalo, NY

Allentown antique district

Buffalo's antique scene benefits from Gilded Age mansions and proximity to Canadian imports. Allentown, Elmwood Village, and Hertel Avenue offer distinct shopping experiences, from Victorian antiques to mid-century modern, with Niagara Falls nearby.

10+
Stores
8.3★
Avg Rating
Mon
Best Day

Best Antique Stores in Buffalo, NY

Top Rated
Open Sundays
Multi-Vendor
Best Prices

Antique World & Flea Market

Massive selection and variety of items
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Antique FurnitureVintage CollectiblesJewelry

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Ability to find unique, hard-to-find antique items
  • Reasonable pricing for quality antiques
  • Large scale and variety ensuring something for everyone

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Confusing layout and unit numbering system makes navigation difficult
  • Inconsistent vendor availability on weekdays

Antique World & Flea Market is Western New York's largest antique destination, featuring multiple year-round antique shops and a seasonal outdoor flea market (April-October weekends). Browse hundreds of vendors offering authentic antiques including furniture dating back to the 1800s, vintage collectibles, jewelry, artwork, and home decor. The sprawling complex includes specialized shops like Premier Antique Center, Expo Center, and Clarence Hollow Antique Mall, plus on-site restoration services. Customers praise the massive selection, fair pricing, and friendly vendors, noting you can easily spend hours exploring. Perfect for collectors and treasure hunters seeking unique finds.

11111 Main St, Clarence, NY 14031

East Aurora Antique Mall

Variety of items
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique treasures
  • Budget-friendly prices
  • Clean, organized environment

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some empty booths/cases
  • Limited vendors at times

East Aurora Antique Mall features over 200 glass cases and vendor booths filled with vintage collectibles and furniture. The indoor mall is complemented by a weekend flea market outdoors. Visitors appreciate the clean, organized layout and friendly staff. Most items are budget-friendly, with good deals to be found on everything from Pyrex to comic books. Plan for an hour or more to properly explore both the indoor and outdoor sections.

11167 Big Tree Rd, Suite M, East Aurora, NY 14052

Eastridge Antiques

Massive selection and variety - customers praise the enormous inventory and diverse items
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureJewelryCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Endless variety and treasure-hunting experience - customers love the adventure of finding unique items
  • Reasonable prices and frequent promotions - newsletter discounts and sales drive repeat visits
  • Professional organization and cleanliness - well-displayed items and clean facility enhance shopping experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Staff professionalism issues - multiple reviews (8, 9, 10) report rude staff making derogatory comments about customers; additional reviews (6, 14) mention unhelpful or snide interactions
  • Poor visibility and difficult to locate - several reviews note the store is hidden in a mall, not visible from street, hard to find on GPS

Ontario Mall Antiques is a massive 50,000 sq ft multi-vendor antique mall in Rochester, NY featuring 1000+ dealers and over 1 million items. This is a true treasure hunter's destination offering mid-century modern furniture, vintage jewelry, collectible toys, vinyl records, Pyrex, coins, and home décor spanning multiple decades. The professionally organized, well-lit space is perfect for extended browsing—customers regularly spend hours discovering new finds. With constantly refreshed inventory, reasonable mid-range pricing, and frequent promotional sales, there's something for every collector and budget.

1850 East Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14622

Erie Gold Exchange

Exceptional customer service and friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$$
SPECIALTIES
JewelryWatchesCoins

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Professional and courteous staff members
  • Fair and competitive pricing for items
  • Fast, efficient transaction process

Erie Gold Exchange is a single-owner precious metals and jewelry buyer established in 1982 by Todd Czerwinski. Specializing in estate jewelry, vintage watches (Rolex, Omega, Patek Philippe), collectible coins, and diamonds, they offer quick transactions with fair pricing and honest service. The shop provides custom ring design, watch battery replacement, and link adjustment services. With two convenient locations and 43+ years of tri-state experience, they accept all major payment forms and offer 90-day layaway options. Customers consistently praise their friendly, knowledgeable staff and efficient service.

2256 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505

Henrietta Mall Antiques

Helpful staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
Antiques & CollectiblesJewelry & DécorArtwork & Paintings

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Friendly, attentive staff
  • Organization and cleanliness
  • Finding unique treasures

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Items locked in glass cases
  • Some items overpriced

Henrietta Mall Antiques is a 10,000 square foot multi-vendor antique mall in Rochester, NY, featuring diverse collections from numerous dealers. Browse unique treasures including vintage jewelry, paintings and prints from the 1800s to today, toys, sports memorabilia, and home décor. The bright, clean showroom offers ample parking and complimentary coffee. Located in Rochester's shopping district near Sticky Lips BBQ, this family-owned destination (operating since 1982) is committed to customer service and product value.

945 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

Old Chapel Market

Vast variety and selection of items across multiple categories
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Antiques & CollectiblesVintage Records & MediaLocal Artisan Crafts

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique, one-of-a-kind items not found elsewhere
  • Friendly and helpful staff
  • Fair prices and good value

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Poor wheelchair accessibility and limited mobility accommodation
  • Overcrowded booths requiring items to be moved to see merchandise

Old Chapel Market is a vast multi-vendor antique destination housed in a beautifully repurposed historic church in North Tonawanda, NY. With over 100 vendors across multiple floors, this unique venue offers an extensive selection of genuine antiques, vintage collectibles, records, CDs, jewelry, and local artisan crafts. Customers consistently praise the 'amazing variety' and 'reasonable prices', with many spending hours exploring the packed rooms and nooks. The store's original stained glass windows and historic architecture add to its charm, making it a destination for both serious collectors and gift shoppers seeking one-of-a-kind Buffalo-themed items and vintage treasures.

172 Robinson St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
Open Daily

Ridge Coin & Jewelry Exchange

Exceptional honesty and fair pricing—customers consistently praise transparent valuations and best-price guarantees
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Precious MetalsCoins & CurrencyJewelry & Watches

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Fair and honest pricing—customers value transparent evaluation and best-price guarantees
  • Professional, courteous staff—personable service and knowledgeable assistance create comfort and trust
  • Superior payouts—customers appreciate receiving significantly more than competitors offer

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional counterfeit items sold (1 review reported fake Rolex and Cartier watches purchased for $4,000)
  • Lower payouts than some jewelry stores on certain items (1 customer received $350 vs. $1,350 elsewhere, though Ridge later offered more)

Ridge Coin & Jewelry Exchange is Rochester's premier precious metals dealer since 1972. Specializing in gold, silver, diamonds, and rare coins, this single-location shop offers free appraisals, fair market prices, and honest transactions. Known for exceptional customer service and transparent evaluations, they buy estate jewelry and collections while selling certified coins and bullion. Staff expertise spans 50 years in precious metals. Quick transactions with cash payouts on the spot.

945 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

Salamanca Mall Antiques

Massive selection and variety - customers repeatedly mention 'huge,' 'endless items,' 'something for everyone'
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Furniture & FurnishingsVintage Toys & CollectiblesJewelry & Coins

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Sheer scale and variety - customers love the massive selection and endless browsing possibilities
  • Staff helpfulness - friendly, knowledgeable staff who assist with finding items and negotiating prices
  • Treasure-hunting experience - customers enjoy the discovery aspect and finding unique, rare items

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Aggressive closing procedures - multiple customers report being rushed out 15-45 minutes before official closing time
  • Inconsistent pricing and some overpriced items - several reviews mention certain vendors charging excessive prices (e.g., $100 Pyrex bowls), though others note good deals available

Salamanca Mall Antiques is New York's largest antique mall, featuring 1,000+ dealers across 30,000+ square feet with over 1 million items. This multi-vendor destination specializes in furniture, vintage collectibles, jewelry, books, tools, and pre-20th century treasures. Family-owned since 1982, the mall is meticulously organized with helpful staff and offers something for every collector. Plan 2-4 hours minimum to explore the vast selection. Mid-range pricing with frequent sales and negotiable prices through staff assistance. A true half-day destination for serious antique hunters.

100 Main St, Salamanca, NY 14779

Small World Books

Extensive book selection
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
Books/PaperCollectiblesVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding rare/unique books
  • Fair prices
  • Personalized service

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Neighborhood safety
  • Space can feel cramped

Housed in a converted building with multiple rooms and floors, Small World Books offers a vast collection of used and rare books spanning countless genres. The cozy atmosphere invites extended browsing among overflowing shelves where treasures await discovery. Beyond books, visitors can find vintage items, art, and collectibles. The friendly owner, store cat Rex, and occasional music events add character to this beloved Rochester institution.

425 North St, Rochester, NY 14605
Open Mon-Sat

The Shops On West Ridge

Vast selection and variety - customers find something new on every visit
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureAntiques & Vintage CollectiblesHome Decor

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique, hard-to-find items not available elsewhere
  • Fair pricing on most items with frequent promotional discounts
  • Welcoming atmosphere and genuine customer service from staff and vendors

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Inventory quality concerns - some customers report fewer true antiques than advertised, more vintage/modern items
  • Pricing inconsistency - one customer reported 4-5x markups on specific items compared to big box stores

The Shops on West Ridge is Rochester's premier antique and vintage destination spanning nearly 60,000 square feet across two floors. This multi-vendor mall features 60+ independent vendors offering an eclectic mix of antique furniture, Mid-Century Modern decor, vintage collectibles, tools, artwork, and home treasures. Customers consistently describe it as a half-day adventure with something for everyone—from high-end furniture pieces to vintage toys, comic books, and artisan jewelry. The store hosts monthly special events including First Saturday treasure hunts, Thursday fresh inventory days, and seasonal celebrations. An on-site café and friendly, knowledgeable staff enhance the browsing experience.

3200 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

Best Stores in Buffalo, NY Map

Map loading...

Best Times to Visit

  • Season: May-October (avoid lake effect snow)
  • Parking: Easy - street parking available most areas

Shopping Tips

  • Allentown First Fridays include galleries and antiques.
  • Canadian antiques require documentation if exporting.
  • Many mansions being restored provide salvage.
  • Estate sales strong due to population shifts.

Dining Options

  • Numerous restaurants in Buffalo, NY area
  • Plan a full day trip with dining
  • Local cafes and eateries nearby

Frequently Asked Questions about Buffalo, NY