Old Chapel Market
172 Robinson St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
$$
PRICE RANGE
Standard Store
STORE SIZE
Store Overview
Old Chapel Market is a vast multi-vendor antique destination housed in a beautifully repurposed historic church in North Tonawanda, NY. With over 100 vendors across multiple floors, this unique venue offers an extensive selection of genuine antiques, vintage collectibles, records, CDs, jewelry, and local artisan crafts. Customers consistently praise the 'amazing variety' and 'reasonable prices', with many spending hours exploring the packed rooms and nooks. The store's original stained glass windows and historic architecture add to its charm, making it a destination for both serious collectors and gift shoppers seeking one-of-a-kind Buffalo-themed items and vintage treasures.
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
TYPICAL VISIT
Half-Day Destination
What Makes This Store Special
Store Features
Multiple Floors
Multi-Vendor
Auctions
Delivery Service
Shipping Available
Historic Building
Customer Insights
8.5/10
Satisfaction Drivers
Unique, one-of-a-kind items not found elsewhere
77%
Friendly and helpful staff
81%
Fair prices and good value
87%
Beautiful historic venue and architecture
91%
What Customers Love
Vast variety and selection of items across multiple categories
Reasonable and fair pricing
Friendly, helpful, and kind staff and owners
Beautiful historic church venue with unique architecture
Multiple floors and rooms to explore; easy to spend hours browsing
Areas for Improvement
Poor wheelchair accessibility and limited mobility accommodation
Overcrowded booths requiring items to be moved to see merchandise
No air conditioning (hot in summer)
Some customers feel it leans more toward craft show items than true antiques
Overall Customer Sentiment
Overwhelmingly positive and enthusiastic. Customers express genuine delight and affection for the store, using words like 'love', 'wonderful', 'amazing', and 'favorite'. Many describe it as a destination worth visiting and returning to.
Store Hours
Checking hours...
Sunday
10:00 AM - 6:00 PM