Paradise Records and Trading Post (Orcutt)
4869 S Bradley Rd, #127, Santa Maria, CA 93455
$$
PRICE RANGE
Larger Store
STORE SIZE
Store Overview
Paradise Records and Trading Post is a sprawling collectibles destination in Santa Maria featuring an eclectic mix of vinyl records, trading cards, comic books, vintage toys, and memorabilia. The spacious store offers rows of vinyl across all music genres, extensive sports card and Pokemon collections, vintage electronics, and one-of-a-kind items. Owner Mike and his knowledgeable team provide friendly service and buy, sell, and trade collectibles. With a VIP membership program and drive-thru service, it's a must-visit for collectors seeking hidden gems and nostalgic treasures.
STORE SIZE
Larger Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
TYPICAL VISIT
Half-Day Destination
What Makes This Store Special
Store Features
Multiple Floors
Multi-Vendor
Auctions
Delivery Service
Shipping Available
Historic Building
Customer Insights
9/10
Satisfaction Drivers
Knowledgeable, personable staff (Mike, Miguel, Issa, Erik mentioned by name)
82%
Overwhelming variety and eclectic inventory spanning multiple decades
86%
Fair trade-in values and willingness to negotiate on pricing
92%
What Customers Love
Exceptional customer service and friendly, knowledgeable staff
Huge selection and variety of collectibles, records, and vintage items
Great deals and fair pricing with VIP discounts available
Areas for Improvement
Some items priced higher than market value (records 2x Discogs prices, Pokemon cards overpriced)
Potential for resealed/counterfeit trading card packs
Overall Customer Sentiment
Enthusiastic and nostalgic; customers express genuine appreciation for the store's unique atmosphere and staff. Many describe it as a 'hidden gem' and 'diamond in the rough' that evokes childhood memories.
Store Hours
Checking hours...
Monday
Closed