Antique store · Lancaster, Ohio
Olde Shoe Factory Antique Mall
301 Forest Rose Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
39.7165° N 82.6063° W
Olde Shoe Factory Antique Mall is an antique store at 301 Forest Rose Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130.
About the shop
The Olde Shoe Factory Antique Mall is a massive 60,000 square foot multi-vendor destination housed in a historic converted shoe factory in Lancaster, Ohio. With over 200 booths spread across three floors, this is the area's largest antique mall offering an incredible variety of genuine antiques and vintage items including glassware, pottery, primitives, coins, Fenton and Cambridge glass, metal signs, and a specialized 'It's a Man's World' section featuring farm equipment, automotive items, and tools. Customers consistently praise the treasure-hunt experience, with most recommending 2-3 hours minimum to explore all three levels. Located minutes from Hocking Hills, the air-conditioned historic building features helpful staff, bathrooms, and easy parking.
From directory research
What you'll find
Glassware & PotteryVintage Advertising & AutomotiveTools & Farm Equipment
Compiled by AntiqueStoresNearby from public listings and reviews
The particulars
- Shop format
- Multi-Vendor MallFrom directory research
- Shop size
- Vast WarehouseFrom directory research
- Price range
- $$$From directory research
- Typical visit
- Half-Day DestinationFrom directory research
- Multiple dealers
- YesFrom directory research
- Multiple floors
- YesFrom directory research
What reviewers mention
Praised
- Massive selection and variety across 3 floors - customers describe it as 'huge', 'treasure hunt', 'can spend hours'
- Genuine antiques and quality pieces - reviews confirm 'true antique store', 'period pieces', 'quality pieces for architectural repurpose'
- Well-organized and pleasant browsing experience - customers mention 'beautifully staged booths', 'relaxing to walk around', 'well played out'
Keeps people coming back
- Vast selection and variety - customers love the 'treasure hunt' aspect and never knowing what they'll find
- Authentic antiques and quality pieces - customers appreciate genuine vintage/antique items over reproductions
- Multi-floor layout and historic building atmosphere - the scale and charming historic setting enhance the experience
Worth knowing
- Prices are high/inflated - multiple reviews mention 'insane prices', 'really expensive', 'prices a bit inflated', price discrepancies between tags and checkout
- Credit card surcharge (3.69%) not clearly communicated - customers report surprise fees and lack of signage
- No returns policy not clearly communicated - at least one customer was unaware and unhappy
- Accessibility issues - wheelchair users report building is 'completely inaccessible' with stairs immediately inside entrance
- Some vendor booths have lower quality 'yard sale leftovers' mixed with quality antiques
Our analysis of public reviews — a summary of what people wrote, not a star rating. Tone: Enthusiastic and positive overall, with customers expressing genuine excitement about discoveries and the experience. Some frustration about pricing transparency and policies. Strong recommendation tone from repeat visitors..
Make a day of it
- 1Tracie Lynn's Collection113 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 431300.2 mi
- 2Curry's Antiques1333 Rockmill Rd NW, Lancaster, OH 431306.3 mi
- 3Sugar Grove Antiques LLC109 S Main St, Sugar Grove, OH 431557.0 mi
- 4Old Barn Co. LLC626 W Market St, Baltimore, OH 431058.9 mi
- 5Spring Street Antique Mall26782 US, Rockbridge, OH 4314911 mi
- 6Hocking Hills Antique Mall26790 US, Rockbridge, OH 4314911 mi