Antique store · Oakdale, New York
Oakdale Antiques Plaza
1236 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769
40.7415° N 73.1306° W
Oakdale Antiques Plaza is an antique store at 1236 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769.
About the shop
Oakdale Antiques Plaza is a beloved multi-vendor antique store in Oakdale, NY, featuring a diverse selection of furniture, vintage watches, clocks, trains, nautical relics, and collectibles. Owner Joe and staff Kirk and Rob are known for their expertise, honesty, and exceptional customer service. The store offers watch repair, restoration consultation, and estate buying services. With constantly changing inventory and fair pricing, it's a treasure-hunting destination for collectors seeking everything from 1900s oak desks to vintage records and restored antique radios.
From directory research
Before you go
Mentioned in public reviews: Auctions. Confirm with the shop.
What you'll find
FurnitureWatches & TimepiecesVintage Collectibles
Compiled by AntiqueStoresNearby from public listings and reviews
The particulars
- Shop format
- Multi-Vendor MallFrom directory research
- Shop size
- Larger StoreFrom directory research
- Price range
- $$From directory research
- Typical visit
- Extended BrowseFrom directory research
- Multiple dealers
- YesFrom directory research
What reviewers mention
Praised
- Friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful staff (mentioned in 20+ reviews)
- Great selection with diverse inventory and fair/reasonable prices (mentioned in 15+ reviews)
- Hidden gem quality with constantly changing merchandise and treasure-hunting experience (mentioned in 10+ reviews)
Keeps people coming back
- Personal attention and genuine care from owners (Kirk and Joe go above and beyond, like contacting customer about gold chain value)
- Reasonable pricing and fair deals that feel honest rather than exploitative
- Diverse, well-organized inventory with something for everyone and constantly refreshed stock
Worth knowing
- Occasional pricing inconsistency or lack of transparency (1 review mentions eye-rolling and disinterest when pricing was requested)
- Staff rudeness when negotiating purchases (1 review describes staff getting upset during price negotiation)
Our analysis of public reviews — a summary of what people wrote, not a star rating. Tone: Overwhelmingly positive and enthusiastic. Customers express genuine affection for the store and owners, using words like 'treasure chest,' 'hidden gem,' 'fabulous,' and 'incredible.' Long-term loyalty is evident with multiple customers mentioning 15-25+ year relationships..
Make a day of it
- 1Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center901 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 117690.7 mi
- 2The Geranium Shed901 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 117690.7 mi
- 3Sayville Antiques136 A Main St, Sayville, NY 117822.5 mi
- 4Paper Doll Vintage Boutique106 Railroad Ave, Sayville, NY 117822.5 mi
- 5Luis Restorations, Inc.1675 Roosevelt Ave Suite B, Bohemia, NY 117163.0 mi
- 6Balcony Art & Antiques at Willow Wood25 Moffitt Blvd, East Islip, NY 117303.4 mi