Antique store · Lake Grove, New York
Antique Attics
2789 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755
40.8600° N 73.1109° W
Antique Attics is an antique store at 2789 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755.
About the shop
Antique Attics is a small, family-run multi-vendor antique and collectibles shop in Lake Grove, NY, offering an eclectic mix of treasures including vintage furniture, costume jewelry, records, toys, video games, and nostalgic memorabilia. With constantly rotating inventory from multiple dealers, customers consistently find unique items at reasonable prices. The warm, welcoming staff and owners are known for going above and beyond—even finding specific items for customers within 48 hours. Perfect for collectors, dealers, and anyone seeking hidden gems with a touch of nostalgia.
From directory research
Before you go
Mentioned in public reviews: Auctions. Confirm with the shop.
What you'll find
Antiques & CollectiblesVintage Records & MediaJewelry & Watches
Compiled by AntiqueStoresNearby from public listings and reviews
The particulars
- Shop format
- Multi-Vendor MallFrom directory research
- Shop size
- Small ShopFrom directory research
- Price range
- $$From directory research
- Typical visit
- Extended BrowseFrom directory research
- Multiple dealers
- YesFrom directory research
What reviewers mention
Praised
- Exceptional customer service and friendly, welcoming staff/owners
- Great prices and reasonable, fair, affordable pricing compared to other antique stores
- Diverse, constantly changing inventory with something for everyone
Keeps people coming back
- Personal, family-oriented service and genuine care from owners/staff
- Affordable pricing that doesn't sacrifice quality or selection
- Organized, clean store with nostalgic atmosphere and curated displays
Worth knowing
- Occasional inventory mismatches (items sold before customer arrival despite being advertised)
- One customer reported unprofessional behavior and perceived favoritism toward novice buyers
Our analysis of public reviews — a summary of what people wrote, not a star rating. Tone: Overwhelmingly positive and enthusiastic. Customers express genuine affection for the store, using words like 'love', 'adore', 'treasure trove', 'hidden gem', and 'feel good'. Strong sense of loyalty and repeat visits..
Make a day of it
- 1Ronkonkoma Rare Coins & Books Inc283 Portion Rd, Lake, Ronkonkoma, NY 117792.3 mi
- 2Lenz Antique$420 Hawkins Ave, Lake, Ronkonkoma, NY 117792.5 mi
- 3Christopher W. Swift Antiques and Interiors535A N Country Rd, St James, NY 117803.1 mi
- 4Luis Restorations, Inc.1675 Roosevelt Ave Suite B, Bohemia, NY 117165.3 mi
- 5Gonzalez Thrift Store3723 NY, Unit f, Coram, NY 117275.9 mi
- 6Lavender Fields250 E Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 117776.3 mi