Antique Attics
2789 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755
$$
PRICE RANGE
Smaller Store
STORE SIZE
Store Overview
Antique Attics is a small, family-run multi-vendor antique and collectibles shop in Lake Grove, NY, offering an eclectic mix of treasures including vintage furniture, costume jewelry, records, toys, video games, and nostalgic memorabilia. With constantly rotating inventory from multiple dealers, customers consistently find unique items at reasonable prices. The warm, welcoming staff and owners are known for going above and beyond—even finding specific items for customers within 48 hours. Perfect for collectors, dealers, and anyone seeking hidden gems with a touch of nostalgia.
STORE SIZE
Small Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
TYPICAL VISIT
Extended Browse
What Makes This Store Special
Store Features
Multiple Floors
Multi-Vendor
Auctions
Delivery Service
Shipping Available
Historic Building
Customer Insights
9/10
Satisfaction Drivers
Personal, family-oriented service and genuine care from owners/staff
82%
Affordable pricing that doesn't sacrifice quality or selection
86%
Organized, clean store with nostalgic atmosphere and curated displays
92%
What Customers Love
Exceptional customer service and friendly, welcoming staff/owners
Great prices and reasonable, fair, affordable pricing compared to other antique stores
Diverse, constantly changing inventory with something for everyone
Areas for Improvement
Occasional inventory mismatches (items sold before customer arrival despite being advertised)
One customer reported unprofessional behavior and perceived favoritism toward novice buyers
Overall Customer Sentiment
Overwhelmingly positive and enthusiastic. Customers express genuine affection for the store, using words like 'love', 'adore', 'treasure trove', 'hidden gem', and 'feel good'. Strong sense of loyalty and repeat visits.
Contact Information
ADDRESS
2789 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755
WEBSITE
PHONE
Store Hours
Checking hours...
Monday
Closed