Antique store · Highland, Indiana
America's Antique Mall - Highland
8311 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322
41.5611° N 87.4699° W
America's Antique Mall - Highland is an antique store at 8311 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322.
About the shop
America's Antique Mall Highland is a massive 60,000 square-foot multi-vendor marketplace featuring hundreds of thousands of items across diverse categories. While marketed as an antique mall, the inventory is a mixed collection of genuine antiques, vintage items, collectibles (Funko Pops, trading cards, sports memorabilia), farmhouse decor, and modern crafts. The clean, bright, air-conditioned space features wide aisles, organized booth sections, and an on-site cafe. Customers appreciate the vast selection and half-day browsing experience, though many note the majority of inventory is vintage/collectible rather than true antiques. Prices range from moderate to high, with some vendor booths offering premium pricing.
From directory research
What you'll find
CollectiblesVintage ItemsFurniture
Compiled by AntiqueStoresNearby from public listings and reviews
The particulars
- Shop format
- Multi-Vendor MallFrom directory research
- Shop size
- Vast WarehouseFrom directory research
- Price range
- $$$From directory research
- Typical visit
- Half-Day DestinationFrom directory research
- Multiple dealers
- YesFrom directory research
What reviewers mention
Praised
- Massive selection and variety of items to browse
- Clean, well-organized, spacious layout with wide aisles
- Great destination for spending hours exploring and treasure hunting
Keeps people coming back
- Enormous selection and variety ensuring something for everyone
- Clean, organized, comfortable shopping environment with amenities (cafe, bathrooms, parking)
- Friendly, helpful staff and welcoming atmosphere
Worth knowing
- Significant presence of fake/counterfeit items (fake trading cards, knockoff purses) with inconsistent vendor quality control
- Overpriced inventory relative to market value; many items priced well above fair value
- Misleading marketing as 'antique mall' when majority of inventory is modern collectibles, flea market items, and crafts rather than genuine antiques
Our analysis of public reviews — a summary of what people wrote, not a star rating. Tone: Customers express enthusiasm about the browsing experience and variety, with nostalgic appreciation for finding vintage items. However, frustration emerges regarding authenticity concerns, pricing, and the disconnect between marketing and actual inventory composition. Staff interactions are generally positive..
Make a day of it
- 1Scarce Collectibles & Antiques8311 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 463220.0 mi
- 2Hammond Salvage and Resale6730 Columbia Ave, Hammond, IN 463242.6 mi
- 3It's Just Serendipity5630 Hohman Ave, Hammond, IN 463204.4 mi
- 4The Vintage Vault1423 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 463114.6 mi
- 5InMyYardSale10248 S Indianapolis Ave, Chicago, IL 6061711 mi
- 6Miller School Shops & Spaces665 S Lake St, Gary, IN 4640311 mi