American Daydream
3790 E Market St, York, PA 17402
$$
PRICE RANGE
Larger Store
STORE SIZE
Store Overview
American Daydream is a vibrant multi-vendor collectibles barn in York, PA specializing in vintage toys, records, comic books, and pop culture memorabilia from the 1950s-1990s. With dozens of curated vendors offering constantly changing inventory, this well-organized store features everything from vintage video games and horror memorabilia to local artisan products. Owners Greg and Maria are known for their personal service and willingness to hunt down rare items. Perfect for elder millennials and collectors seeking nostalgic treasures in a fun, quirky atmosphere.
STORE SIZE
Larger Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
TYPICAL VISIT
Half-Day Destination
What Makes This Store Special
Store Features
Multiple Floors
Multi-Vendor
Auctions
Delivery Service
Shipping Available
Historic Building
Customer Insights
9/10
Satisfaction Drivers
Treasure-hunting experience with constantly changing inventory
82%
Nostalgic connection to childhood memories and pop culture
86%
Friendly, helpful owners and vendors who create welcoming community atmosphere
92%
What Customers Love
Incredible variety and selection of unique items across multiple categories
Fun, quirky, nostalgic atmosphere that evokes childhood memories and wonder
Well-organized, friendly owners (Greg and Maria) with excellent customer service and willingness to help find specific items
Areas for Improvement
Pricing higher than online comparables (eBay sold prices) - customers advised to check online first
Quality control issues with some inventory (damaged records, expired products)
Small parking lot and dusty conditions
Overall Customer Sentiment
Enthusiastic, nostalgic, and delighted. Customers express genuine excitement and emotional connection to the store, describing it as a 'gem,' 'treasure hunt,' and 'trip back in time.' Many visit multiple times monthly and recommend it highly.
Store Hours
Checking hours...
Sunday
10:00 AM - 6:00 PM