Top Antique Destination
Updated October 2025

Top 10 Antique Stores in Milwaukee, WI

The best-rated stores and markets in America's Antiques Capital

Rankings based on customer reviews, selection quality, dealer variety, and overall shopping experience

The Definitive Top 10

From massive warehouses with hundreds of dealers to specialized boutiques with curated collections, these are the must-visit destinations that make Milwaukee, WI the undisputed antique capital of America.

Top 10 Antique Stores List

American Antiques and Jewelry

Excellent customer service
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
JewelryAntiquesCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Personalized shopping experience
  • Quality of jewelry
  • Fair prices

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional shipping issues
  • One complaint about pricing/valuation

American Antiques and Jewelry specializes in vintage and antique jewelry with an impressive selection ranging from rings and pendants to bracelets and charms. Known for their responsive text-based customer service, they offer layaway options and fast shipping. Many customers discover them through TikTok lives where they showcase their extensive inventory. Family-owned with knowledgeable staff who provide personalized assistance in finding unique pieces.

2545 W Mason St, Green Bay, WI 54303

Harp Gallery Antiques and Vintage Furniture

High quality restoration work
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureDecorative ItemsArt

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Quality of restoration
  • Professional delivery service
  • Accurate online descriptions and photos

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • High prices
  • Shipping costs

Harp Gallery showcases beautifully restored antique and vintage furniture in a stunning showroom complete with curved stone staircases. Their meticulously refinished pieces include everything from Art Deco vanities to Tudor beds and mission furniture. Known for exceptional restoration quality and white glove delivery nationwide, customers rave about furniture that arrives looking 'even better than the photos.' Their constantly changing inventory keeps collectors returning regularly.

2101 Progress Way, Kaukauna, WI 54130

Neenah Vintage Mall

Clean and well-organized
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesVintage/PrimitivesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Variety of items
  • Nostalgic finds
  • Fair pricing

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Inventory turnover rate
  • Limited mask usage during pandemic

Housed in a former grocery storefront, Neenah Vintage Mall offers a well-organized treasure hunt through numerous vendor booths featuring everything from vintage collectibles to handcrafted items. The clean, bright space showcases a 50/50 mix of true antiques and creative repurposed goods at notably reasonable prices. Shoppers appreciate the friendly staff, seasonal displays, and ever-changing inventory that rewards repeat visits.

884 S Commercial St, Neenah, WI 54956
Open Mon-Sat

School Days Mall Antiques

Extensive selection
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique building atmosphere
  • Variety of merchandise
  • Treasure-hunting experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Accessibility issues for wheelchairs/mobility
  • Some overpriced items

Housed in a charming old school building with three floors of treasures, School Days Mall Antiques offers a sprawling maze of booths filled with reasonably priced collectibles, furniture, and vintage items. Each classroom-turned-vendor space presents unique finds from Pyrex to vinyl records. Plan to spend several hours exploring the many rooms and levels, as customers consistently mention needing multiple visits to see everything. Staff are noted for their friendliness and historical knowledge about items.

9500 Durand Ave, Sturtevant, WI 53177
Open Daily

Antiques on Pierce

Vast selection and variety
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureArtCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Treasure-hunting experience
  • Unique/unusual items
  • Well-organized despite size

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • Overwhelming for some visitors

Housed in a historic industrial building, this massive four-floor antique warehouse features 140+ vendors with an extraordinary selection. The third floor's impressive Asian art and artifacts collection feels museum-like, while furniture dominates the top floor. Clean, well-organized spaces showcase everything from vintage clothing to unique collectibles. Plan at least 3-4 hours to explore - most visitors can't see it all in one trip!

1512 W Pierce St, 244 1512, Milwaukee, WI 53204

BENSON CORNERS ANTIQUE MALL

Great variety and selection
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesVintage ItemsGlassware

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique items/treasures
  • Reasonable prices on most items
  • Extensive selection across two buildings

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items overpriced
  • Occasional reports of unfriendly staff

Benson Corners features two separate buildings packed with treasures from numerous vendors. Known for its wide variety of collectibles, vintage items, and beautiful glassware, this clean and well-organized mall offers everything from toys and records to household antiques. With constantly changing inventory and frequent sales, plan to spend several hours exploring both buildings. Prices are generally reasonable, and the friendly staff enhances the treasure-hunting experience.

19942 75th St, Bristol, WI 53104

Electric Groove Music & More / Antique Up

Vast selection
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesVinyl RecordsVintage Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique items
  • Friendly staff
  • Spacious layout

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Slow checkout process
  • Some overpriced items

This massive U-shaped antique mall houses hundreds of vendor booths across two expansive warehouse wings. Visitors consistently need 3+ hours to explore the labyrinth of collectibles, vinyl records, and vintage treasures. Known for its sheer size and variety, the mall features well-organized booths with reasonably priced merchandise spanning decades. The vinyl selection receives particular praise, alongside military memorabilia and vintage advertising.

850 E Maes Ave, Kimberly, WI 54136
Open Mon-Sat

Great Lakes Antiques Boutique

Friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Decorative ItemsCollectiblesFurniture

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique finds
  • Variety of merchandise
  • Nostalgic experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Inconsistent customer service
  • Some overpriced items

This expansive multi-vendor antique mall offers room after room of treasures with both indoor and outdoor displays. Featuring everything from Fenton glass collections to vintage furniture and handcrafted items. The shop includes a coffee café where visitors can take a break while exploring. Plan to spend 1-2 hours browsing through the many booths, each with its own unique specialty. Don't miss the chicken coop outside!

1615 Main St, Antioch, IL 60002

Originals Mall of Antiques

Vast selection
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique treasures
  • Nostalgic experience
  • Variety of vendors

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items overpriced
  • Occasional rude staff encounters

This enormous antique mall houses countless vendors offering a treasure trove of collectibles, vintage items, and furniture. Customers regularly spend 2-5 hours exploring the sprawling space, which many describe as deceptively large. The well-organized booths feature everything from aviation memorabilia to vinyl records and coin collections. With friendly staff and both indoor and outdoor sections, it's a destination requiring ample time to fully appreciate.

1475 S Washburn St, Oshkosh, WI 54904

Waterford Unique Antique Market

Friendly/helpful staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
AntiquesCollectiblesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique items at reasonable prices
  • Pleasant browsing experience
  • Helpful and friendly service

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some complaints about too many craft/non-antique items
  • Occasional staff interactions issues

This well-organized antique mall features a diverse mix of genuine antiques alongside handcrafted items, repurposed furniture, and collectibles. With numerous vendors offering reasonably priced merchandise, shoppers typically spend an hour or more exploring the clean, spacious layout. Staff are notably friendly and will help carry larger purchases to vehicles. The store maintains a good balance of vintage treasures and newer decorative pieces.

318 E Main St, Waterford, WI 53185