Top 10 Antique Stores in Lancaster, PA

Augusta Jewelers and Coins offers a clean, well-organized space where the knowledgeable owner, Leroy, provides exceptional personalized service. Specializing in jewelry, coins, and various collectibles, this shop is known for fair pricing when buying or selling gold and silver. Most customers appreciate the honest appraisals, educational approach, and the owner's friendly, no-pressure demeanor that makes transactions quick and comfortable.

Housed in a historic building in Columbia, Bootleg Antiques offers two floors of carefully curated treasures from 72+ vendors. Beyond the impressive selection of furniture, collectibles, and vintage tools, visitors rave about the in-house café serving beverages, baked goods, and weekend hot meals. Military veterans receive special discounts, making this welcoming space perfect for a half-day antiquing adventure.

Dave's Gold, Antiques, Loan is a well-organized small shop specializing in gold/jewelry, antiques, and collectibles. Owner Dave offers personalized service with expertise in evaluating gold, silver, coins, and vintage items. The clean, treasure-filled space features nostalgic collectibles and quality merchandise at fair prices. Perfect for quick transactions or browsing unique finds, the shop maintains a professional yet friendly atmosphere that keeps customers returning.

JoRetro offers a meticulously curated collection of mid-century treasures with an exceptional Pyrex selection that draws collectors from miles around. The two-floor space showcases vintage clothing (inclusive sizing from small to 5X), retro housewares, and nostalgic collectibles arranged in visually pleasing displays. Family-owned with knowledgeable staff, the store combines authentic vintage pieces with reproduction items that capture the spirit of the 50s-70s era.

The Barnyard Boys specializes in reclaimed lumber, architectural salvage, and custom wood pieces. Their showroom displays various woods, finishes, and handmade furniture with historical significance. Customers praise their custom work - from cutting beams for mantles to creating tables from 200-year-old barn wood. Plan to spend 1-2 hours exploring their extensive selection of vintage doors, windows, and barn hardware.

Spanning three distinct buildings with elevator access, Antique Village of Strasburg offers an extensive collection of treasures from furniture to vintage cameras and tools. Visitors regularly spend hours exploring the varied inventory across multiple floors. While some customers note prices can occasionally run high, many find fair deals on everything from country primitives to outdoor furniture. The diverse vendor spaces create an engaging treasure hunt atmosphere.

Housed in an old mill building with three floors to explore, this spacious antique store boasts an impressive collection of furniture, from country primitives to colonial styles. Visitors highlight the extensive collection of vintage bicycles and quality antiques displayed throughout. With multiple vendors offering diverse treasures at mid-range prices, most shoppers spend 1-2 hours browsing the well-organized spaces.