Top 10 Antique Stores in Columbus, OH

Was New LLC is a cozy thrift/antique shop with a treasure-hunt atmosphere. Packed with everything from power tools and vintage items to affordable furniture, this store rewards those willing to browse. Friendly staff and regular sales (including 20% off days) keep customers returning. The shop offers a blend of new and used merchandise with constantly rotating inventory that makes each visit different.

This unique three-story emporium blends antiques with nostalgic entertainment, featuring vintage arcade and pinball machines alongside collectibles, furniture, and memorabilia. The distinctive soda fountain/ice cream bar and full bar with boozy milkshakes create a destination experience. Visitors typically spend 1-2 hours exploring the main floor, basement, and upper level, discovering everything from vinyl records and VHS tapes to military memorabilia and vintage clothing.

Columbus Architectural Salvage offers a treasure trove of salvaged architectural pieces from historic buildings. This well-organized showroom specializes in rare hardware, vintage doors, mantels, and unique fixtures for restoration projects. Visitors regularly spend hours exploring the meticulously arranged inventory of period-specific items. Perfect for homeowners restoring older properties or designers seeking authentic character pieces that can't be found elsewhere.

Housed in a historic building with five sprawling floors, this labyrinthine antique mall features countless rooms that seemingly go on forever. Visitors consistently get lost exploring the maze-like layout filled with vintage treasures from approximately 50 vendors. The intercom system throughout helps navigate this massive space where everything from unique furniture and vintage clothing to collectibles and quirky memorabilia awaits discovery.

Housed in a massive 53,000 square foot space, Heritage Square Antique Mall offers an overwhelming treasure hunt experience requiring hours to explore. With 400+ vendors selling everything from vintage collectibles and furniture to glassware and vinyl records, visitors frequently mention needing 'a flashlight' due to dim lighting. The well-organized layout includes clearly marked sections and showcase areas featuring higher-end items. Expect to spend at least 2-3 hours browsing this expansive collection.

This spacious multi-vendor antique mall features numerous booths offering an eclectic mix of collectibles, glassware, and decorative items. Visitors regularly spend 1-2 hours exploring the well-organized spaces. While some find treasures at reasonable prices, others note items can be somewhat expensive. The mall has a particularly good selection of vintage items, with everything from uranium glass to model trains drawing specialty collectors.

Housed in a spacious building with numerous vendors, Pickaway Craft Mall offers an eclectic mix of crafts, antiques, collectibles, and vintage items. Customers often spend 1-2 hours exploring the various booths featuring everything from handmade crafts and candles to records, primitives, and unique finds. With reasonable prices and constantly rotating inventory, shoppers appreciate the treasure-hunting experience and friendly staff.