Top Antique Destination
Updated October 2025

Top 10 Antique Stores in Syracuse, NY

The best-rated stores and markets in America's Antiques Capital

Rankings based on customer reviews, selection quality, dealer variety, and overall shopping experience

The Definitive Top 10

From massive warehouses with hundreds of dealers to specialized boutiques with curated collections, these are the must-visit destinations that make Syracuse, NY the undisputed antique capital of America.

Top 10 Antique Stores List

Pay More Pawn

Fair pricing
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
JewelryElectronicsTools/Hardware

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Owner's personalized attention
  • Better prices than competitors
  • Willingness to work with customers in difficult situations

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Limited selection mentioned by a few customers
  • One complaint about gold valuation

Pay More Pawn is a friendly, owner-operated pawn shop specializing in jewelry, electronics, and tools. The store offers fair pricing on both buying and selling, with an emphasis on honest, personalized service. The shop maintains a clean, organized space with a diverse inventory that changes regularly. Perfect for a quick visit when you need cash or are hunting for a specific item at a good value.

7380 Oswego Rd, Liverpool, NY 13090

Bostwick Antique Mall & Auctions

Friendly, helpful staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Diverse selection of antiques
  • Clean, organized space
  • On-site diner

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional customer service issues
  • Some merchandise quality concerns

Bostwick Antique Mall & Auctions offers an expansive, well-organized shopping experience with numerous vendor booths featuring everything from quality furniture to unique collectibles and vintage treasures. The clean, orderly layout makes browsing enjoyable, with most items reasonably priced. A distinctive feature is the on-site diner serving breakfast and lunch, making this a perfect destination for a 1-2 hour treasure hunt with a meal break.

1121 Owego Rd, Candor, NY 13743

Early Owego Antique Center (formerly J.J. Newberry Co.)

Wide variety of merchandise
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Constantly changing inventory
  • Historical building character
  • Diverse selection across many categories

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • No elevator for accessibility

Housed in a former J.J. Newberry department store, this two-story antique center offers an extensive collection from numerous vendors. Visitors consistently mention needing hours to explore both floors packed with collectibles, vintage items, furniture, and records. The historic building adds charm with original floor tiles and architectural details. Staff is generally friendly and helpful, though pricing opinions vary. A true treasure-hunting experience where you'll discover something new with each visit.

43-45 Lake St, Owego, NY 13827

Found In Ithaca

Unique/interesting merchandise
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureVintage/PrimitivesCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique items
  • Variety of merchandise
  • Pleasant browsing experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • Occasional customer service issues

Found In Ithaca occupies a warehouse-style space filled with ever-changing vintage treasures from multiple vendors. Visitors can easily spend an hour or more exploring furniture, jewelry, vintage clothing, and unique collectibles. The layout is well-organized with individual booth spaces, allowing for comfortable browsing through decades of history. Particularly noted for mid-century pieces and unusual finds, this treasure trove draws both casual browsers and serious collectors.

227 Cherry St, Ithaca, NY 14850

ReFabulous Furnishings

Fair prices
STORE FORMAT
Mixed Format
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureDecorative ItemsVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unexpected treasures
  • Ease of consignment process
  • Professional furniture pickup service

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Consignment process transparency
  • Delivery timing issues

ReFabulous Furnishings offers an ever-changing inventory of quality used furniture and home decor through their consignment model. With two floors to explore, shoppers can find everything from dining sets and armoires to unique decorative pieces at fair prices. The store specializes in furniture restoration services, with staff who help customers both buy and sell secondhand treasures. Delivery is available for larger purchases.

2231 Vestal Pkwy W, Vestal, NY 13850

Syracuse Antiques Exchange

Vast selection across multiple floors
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesArt

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique treasures
  • Building-wide treasure hunt experience
  • Helpful staff assistance

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • Limited vendor availability for price negotiations

Spanning four impressive floors, Syracuse Antiques Exchange houses over 70 vendors offering everything from vintage furniture to rare collectibles. Customers regularly spend hours exploring the well-organized spaces filled with treasures from various eras. The friendly staff will contact vendors for price negotiations on higher-end pieces. With constantly rotating inventory and specialty sections for lighting, jewelry, and mid-century items, repeat visits are essential to catch new arrivals.

1629 N Salina St, Syracuse, NY 13208

The Eclectic Chic

Huge selection/variety
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Constantly changing inventory
  • Something for everyone
  • Unique/hard-to-find items

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some overpriced items
  • Occasional staff attitude issues

Housed in a former grocery store, The Eclectic Chic is an enormous multi-vendor marketplace that requires hours to fully explore. Customers consistently mention needing 'half a day' or 'several hours' to navigate the endless aisles packed with collectibles, furniture, and vintage treasures. The store features a café and ice cream shop in the back, making it easy to refuel during your treasure hunt. With hundreds of vendors offering everything from antiques to handcrafted items, inventory constantly changes, ensuring something new on every visit.

2044 Glenwood Shopping Plz, Oneida, NY 13421

Village Buy Cell Repair

Fast service
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
Electronics RepairPhone/Tablet RepairVintage Electronics

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Quick turnaround time
  • Skilled repairs
  • Friendly staff

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional quality issues with repairs
  • Some customer service complaints

Village Buy Cell Repair specializes in quick, professional phone and tablet repairs with a focus on iPhones and iPads. This small, cozy shop offers screen replacements, charging port fixes, and water damage recovery at competitive prices. Customers praise the fast turnaround times—often under an hour—and knowledgeable staff. The shop also carries vintage cameras, gaming systems, and other electronics collectibles to browse while waiting for repairs.

Geneva Antique Co-Op

Variety of merchandise
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesVintage/PrimitivesTools/Hardware

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unexpected treasures
  • Fair pricing
  • Extensive inventory

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional poor customer service
  • Cleanliness issues in basement

Housed across two packed floors including a treasure-filled basement, Geneva Antique Co-Op offers an extensive variety of reasonably priced collectibles, vintage items, and nostalgic treasures. Comic enthusiasts will appreciate the substantial collection of boxes to dig through, while others can explore everything from 80s-90s memorabilia to antique tools. Plan for 1-2 hours to properly explore this co-op's many booths filled with constantly rotating inventory.

475 Exchange St, Geneva, NY 14456

Ontario Mall Antiques Corporation

Enormous selection
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Treasure hunting experience
  • Nostalgic finds
  • Unexpected discoveries

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Staff rudeness/impatience
  • Inconsistent pricing

Ontario Mall Antiques Corporation is an enormous antique mall featuring hundreds of vendors under one roof. Plan to spend at least 3-4 hours exploring the vast selection of collectibles, furniture, and decorative items. The layout is well-organized with countless glass display cases for smaller valuables and open areas for furniture. Staff are available to unlock cases for closer inspection. With constantly rotating inventory, even regular visitors discover new treasures with each visit.

1740 Rochester Rd, #332, Farmington, NY 14425