Top 10 Antique Stores in New Haven, CT

A spacious, well-organized antique center tucked away in a quiet plaza, offering a diverse selection of collectibles, furniture, and vinyl records. The clean, gallery-like atmosphere makes browsing comfortable, with friendly staff and fair pricing. Customers regularly spend hours exploring the ever-changing inventory, discovering everything from vintage electronics to nostalgic toys. Perfect for collectors seeking that unique conversation piece.

Nestled alongside the Peconic River, this enchanting plant nursery and garden center offers an immersive experience beyond typical shopping. With acres of beautifully landscaped grounds featuring unique plants, herbs, garden decor, and antique items, visitors often spend hours exploring the peaceful property. The farm's picnic areas by the water, hidden nooks, and greenhouse make it a perfect day trip destination that feels like 'a magical fairyland' with shopping opportunities.

Step into a vibrant time capsule at The Times Vintage, a beautifully curated shop with authentic vintage clothing, vinyl records, and nostalgic home goods from the 50s-90s. The thoughtfully decorated space creates an immersive retro experience that feels like 'walking onto a movie set.' Customers frequently spend hours exploring the eclectic selection, from quality vintage fashion to an extensive record collection, all while enjoying the store's distinctive 60s-70s ambiance.

Atlantis Antiques is a treasure-filled shop run by Guy Ferraro, a deeply knowledgeable and honest dealer specializing in quality furniture, art, and jewelry. The store operates primarily by appointment, offering personalized service rather than casual browsing. Customers consistently praise Guy's expertise, fairness in pricing, and willingness to educate about antiques, making this a destination for those seeking both purchases and appraisals.

Cindy's Unique Shop offers a beautifully curated consignment experience that feels more like an upscale gift shop than a typical second-hand store. With meticulously arranged displays spanning multiple floors, visitors can spend hours discovering everything from handmade Japanese tapestries to brass animal lamps. The woman-owned, family-run business specializes in quality home décor, collectibles, and unique furniture pieces at surprisingly reasonable prices.

This charming multi-dealer antique center offers a tight but well-organized space packed with quality mid-range treasures. With 10 vendors constantly refreshing inventory, you'll discover everything from vintage jewelry and glassware to nautical collectibles and unique furniture. The main space connects to a barn area out back, creating an engaging browsing experience that typically requires 1-2 hours to fully explore. Particularly noted for its Hamptons-area collectibles.

The Trove features two distinct buildings packed with antiques and collectibles. Don't miss the second building in back, which many reviewers highlight as essential to the full experience. With friendly staff and a wide array of furniture, decorative items, and collectibles from multiple vendors, you'll easily spend 1-2 hours exploring both spaces. Prices range from reasonable finds to occasional splurges, with ever-changing inventory that rewards repeat visits.