Top Antique Destination
Updated October 2025

Top 10 Antique Stores in Indianapolis, IN

The best-rated stores and markets in America's Antiques Capital

Rankings based on customer reviews, selection quality, dealer variety, and overall shopping experience

The Definitive Top 10

From massive warehouses with hundreds of dealers to specialized boutiques with curated collections, these are the must-visit destinations that make Indianapolis, IN the undisputed antique capital of America.

Top 10 Antique Stores List

Audrey's Place Thrift Store

Friendly, helpful staff
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureAntiquesCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique finds and treasures
  • Helpful, knowledgeable staff
  • Well-organized layout

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional pricing concerns
  • Limited open hours (closed Sundays)

Audrey's Place is a treasure trove of vintage finds arranged in multiple rooms filled with organized vignettes. Known for quality furniture, unique antiques and architectural salvage for historic homes, this east side Indy institution offers friendly service and fair prices. Customers consistently praise the helpful staff and diverse inventory that changes regularly, making each visit a new adventure worth spending hours exploring.

3228 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201

WILLow LeaVes of Hope

Delicious homestyle food
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
AntiquesFurnitureDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Home-cooked quality meals
  • Charming, nostalgic atmosphere
  • Entertainment value of plays

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional slow service
  • Limited restroom facilities

WILLow LeaVes of Hope offers a charming dual experience - a cozy antique shop in front with vintage furniture and home decor, plus a quaint restaurant serving homestyle meals in back. Visitors can shop for collectibles and unique pieces, then enjoy comfort food or attend one of their popular dinner theater productions. The friendly family atmosphere makes this a perfect spot for browsing and dining in one visit.

326 Jackson St, Hope, IN 47246

Brown County Antique Mall

Friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesJewelryDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Unique finds
  • Helpful staff
  • Multiple buildings to explore

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items considered overpriced
  • Outdoor porta-potties only

Spanning three buildings with a surprising amount of inventory, Brown County Antique Mall offers a treasure trove of collectibles, jewelry, and unique decorative items. Friendly staff welcome visitors to explore well-organized booths featuring everything from geodes and sterling silver to vintage memorabilia. Plan for 1-2 hours to properly browse all three buildings, where you'll likely discover something unexpected at reasonable prices.

3288 IN, Nashville, IN 47448

Days of Old Antique Shoppe

Clean and organized
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Variety of merchandise
  • Clean, organized layout
  • Friendly service

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items overpriced
  • Limited true antiques

Days of Old Antique Shoppe offers a spacious, well-organized multi-vendor experience with a clean, bright atmosphere that customers consistently praise. From vintage furniture and nostalgic collectibles to unique home decor and specialty items like Candleberry candles, the diverse booths provide something for everyone. Expect to spend 1-2 hours browsing the clearly labeled vendor spaces. The friendly, helpful staff and family-owned atmosphere enhance the shopping experience.

3850 25th St, Columbus, IN 47203

Glendy's Uptown Mall

Variety of merchandise
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Treasure-hunting experience
  • Quality and variety of merchandise
  • Pleasant shopping environment

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • Accessibility issues for disabled customers

Glendy's Uptown Mall offers a treasure-hunting experience with numerous vendor booths filled with antiques, vintage items, and unique collectibles. The expansive layout houses everything from quality furniture pieces to nostalgic memorabilia and decorative items. Customers regularly spend hours exploring the well-organized space, appreciating the clean environment and friendly staff. With constantly rotating inventory and reasonable prices on many items, repeat visits are rewarded with new discoveries.

901 Poplar St, Terre Haute, IN 47807

Southport Antique Mall

Vast selection/variety
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesClothing/Textiles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Treasure hunting excitement
  • Nostalgia factor
  • Unexpected finds

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • High prices
  • Slow checkout process

Deceptively enormous, this maze-like antique mall houses an overwhelming variety of treasures that could take days to fully explore. With color-coded floor arrows to navigate its seemingly endless booths and rooms, shoppers discover everything from vintage furniture and Pyrex to an impressive upstairs vintage clothing section. Plan several hours minimum - customers repeatedly note they couldn't see it all in one visit despite spending hours wandering through this unexpectedly vast space.

2028 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Vendors' Village of Terre Haute

Huge variety of items
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Vast selection of merchandise
  • Treasure hunt experience
  • Something for everyone

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some booths overpriced
  • Occasional poor customer service

Housed in the Haute City Center mall, this enormous indoor flea market features countless vendor booths with everything imaginable. Visitors routinely spend hours exploring aisles packed with collectibles, furniture, vintage items, toys, and handcrafted decor. With shopping carts available and clean, organized spaces, it's a treasure hunter's paradise where you'll discover unique items from Pokemon cards to antique Coca-Cola memorabilia at mostly reasonable prices.

In West Side Of Haute City Ctr, 3401 US-41, Terre Haute, IN 47802

Midland Arts & Antiques Market

Huge selection/variety
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesArt

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Constantly changing inventory
  • Unusual/one-of-a-kind finds
  • Immersive browsing experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Inconsistent pricing (some overpriced items)
  • Building temperature issues (hot in summer)

Housed in a historic factory building, Midland Arts & Antiques Market sprawls across 45,000 square feet with over 200 vendors on two floors. This vast warehouse space offers an overwhelming array of furniture, art, and collectibles ranging from mid-century modern pieces to quirky oddities. Customers regularly spend hours exploring the maze-like layout, discovering everything from vintage clothing to taxidermy. The building's industrial character adds to the treasure-hunting experience.

907 E Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Open Daily

Nostalgia on 9

Friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesVintage/PrimitivesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unexpected treasures
  • Regular inventory turnover
  • Friendly atmosphere

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some overpriced items
  • Occasional customer service issues

Housed in an old school building, Nostalgia on 9 offers two floors of treasures with distinct personalities - upstairs featuring quality antiques and collectibles, while the downstairs has more of a flea market feel. Vendors regularly refresh their booths, ensuring new finds with each visit. The clean, well-organized space offers everything from McCoy pottery to vintage toys, with mostly reasonable pricing that keeps customers returning monthly.

1018 E 500 S, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Peddlers Mall Flea Market

Great deals/prices
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesHousehold Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unexpected bargains
  • Variety of merchandise
  • Treasure-hunting experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Cleanliness/maintenance issues
  • Inconsistent customer service

This expansive indoor flea market houses hundreds of vendor booths in a former grocery store space. From furniture and mattresses to collectibles and household items, Peddlers Mall offers an eclectic, treasure-hunt experience that can consume hours. While the facility shows its age and organization varies by booth, bargain hunters continue to find deals amid the maze-like layout. Expect a no-frills shopping environment where persistence often rewards with unexpected finds.

7803 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219