Top Antique Destination
Updated October 2025

Top 10 Antique Stores in Dayton, OH

The best-rated stores and markets in America's Antiques Capital

Rankings based on customer reviews, selection quality, dealer variety, and overall shopping experience

The Definitive Top 10

From massive warehouses with hundreds of dealers to specialized boutiques with curated collections, these are the must-visit destinations that make Dayton, OH the undisputed antique capital of America.

Top 10 Antique Stores List

New Paris Antique Mall

Friendly staff/owners
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Variety and quantity of merchandise
  • Reasonable prices
  • Friendly atmosphere including shop dogs

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Steep stairs to upper floors
  • No elevator mentioned

Housed in a historic Odd Fellows Lodge, this four-floor treasure trove offers an impressive selection across basement, main floor, and two upper levels. Friendly owners and adorable shop dogs welcome visitors to well-organized booths featuring quality antiques, vintage collectibles, and furniture at reasonable prices. The clean, thoughtfully arranged displays create an immersive experience worth scheduling several hours to explore thoroughly.

102 E Main St, New Paris, OH 45347

Belmont Coin & Jewelry

Fair pricing
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Boutique Shop
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
JewelryCoinsPrecious Metals

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Honest transactions
  • Fair prices for gold/silver
  • Helpful staff

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional rudeness
  • Low offers on items

Belmont Coin & Jewelry specializes in coins, precious metals, and fine jewelry with a reputation for fair pricing and knowledgeable staff. This professional, service-oriented shop offers jewelry repair, custom work, and coin appraisals. Customers appreciate the quick transactions and honest evaluations when buying or selling gold, silver, and collectible coins. Most visits are efficient with personalized attention from experienced staff.

2749 Wilmington Pike, Dayton, OH 45419

Brick Rhod Antiques & Bistro

Excellent food and coffee
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesDecorative ItemsVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Combination of bistro and antiques
  • Quality of food/coffee
  • Charming atmosphere

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional service issues
  • Some items considered overpriced

This unique combination antique store and bistro offers a charming shopping experience in historic Lewisburg. The spacious venue features multiple vendor booths with quality collectibles, vintage items, and decorative pieces. Customers particularly enjoy browsing the well-organized antiques after enjoying coffee or a meal in the attached bistro. With upstairs seating and plenty to explore, plan to spend 1-2 hours enjoying both the food and treasure hunting.

109 N Commerce St, Lewisburg, OH 45338

Flory's Antique Depot

Friendly/helpful staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique/unexpected items
  • Helpful staff interactions
  • The joy of discovery on repeat visits

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Inconsistent pricing
  • Occasional staff attitude issues

Housed across two spacious floors, Flory's Antique Depot offers a surprisingly extensive collection that belies its modest exterior. Vendors showcase everything from Victorian treasures to vintage tools and Native American artifacts. Customers frequently spend over an hour exploring without seeing everything, enjoying complimentary popcorn while browsing. The basement holds additional 'goodies' with some vendors willing to negotiate on prices.

316 Hay Ave, Brookville, OH 45309

Lebanon Peddlers Mall

Variety of merchandise
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Discovering unexpected finds
  • Clean, organized space
  • No pressure shopping experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Long checkout lines
  • Some overpriced booths

This expansive peddlers mall features nine long aisles packed with vendor booths selling everything from nostalgic collectibles to vintage furniture. Plan to spend 2-3 hours exploring the maze-like layout where treasures await in every corner. Prices are generally reasonable, though quality varies by booth. Perfect for collectors and browsers alike, with constantly changing inventory that keeps regulars coming back monthly to discover new finds.

920 A Columbus Ave, Lebanon, OH 45036

Lilly's Corner Mall

Reasonable prices
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureDecorative ItemsCollectibles

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique treasures
  • Fair pricing
  • Pleasant browsing experience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasional customer service issues
  • Bathroom policy

Lilly's Corner Mall offers a well-organized space with numerous vendor booths featuring quality antiques at notably reasonable prices. Visitors praise the diverse selection of furniture, vintage decor, and collectibles. The store strikes a balance between being large enough to explore thoroughly without feeling overwhelming. Friendly staff and unique treasures make this a popular stop in Waynesville, with most customers spending an hour or more browsing the ever-changing inventory.

105 S Main St, Waynesville, OH 45068

Midwest Memories Antiques

Friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesFurnitureVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Treasure hunting experience
  • Unique/one-of-a-kind finds
  • Downtown location convenience

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some items perceived as overpriced
  • Limited hours (closes early)

Housed in a deceptively spacious building in downtown Tipp City, Midwest Memories Antiques surprises visitors with its extensive two-floor layout. This multi-vendor mall offers an impressive selection of collectibles, vintage pieces, furniture, and primitives. Friendly staff welcome browsers to explore numerous booths featuring everything from mid-century treasures to tools and handcrafted items. Plan for at least an hour to properly experience this unexpectedly large shop that locals consider a peaceful escape.

24 W Main St, Tipp City, OH 45371

The 3 Weird Sisters Studio, A Collection Of Unusual Things

Unique/unusual items
STORE FORMAT
Single Owner Shop
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesDecorative ItemsVintage/Primitives

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Eclectic and unique inventory
  • Interesting atmosphere
  • Constantly changing selection

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Occasionally overpriced items
  • Customer service inconsistency

This eclectic two-floor shop in downtown Troy offers a constantly changing collection of unique and unusual items, from vintage trinkets to quirky gifts. Known for its weird and wonderful atmosphere, friendly staff, and even shop cats, it's a treasure hunter's paradise where you could spend hours browsing through everything from antiques and collectibles to local honey and handcrafted stickers. The perfect destination for finding that one-of-a-kind gift.

15 S Market St, Troy, OH 45373
Open Tue-Sat

Waynesville Antique Mall

Friendly staff
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Large Store
PRICE RANGE
$
SPECIALTIES
CollectiblesDecorative ItemsGlassware

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Finding unique items
  • Pleasant browsing experience
  • Helpful staff

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some early closures reported
  • Occasional tight aisles/crowded spaces

Housed in a two-story building with 30 separate vendor booths, Waynesville Antique Mall offers an extensive selection of affordable collectibles, vintage glassware, and decorative items. The air-conditioned space features both antiques and crafts, with particular strengths in Ohio-made glass and vinyl records. Visitors typically spend 1-2 hours exploring both floors, with comfortable benches provided for those needing a rest.

69 S Main St, Waynesville, OH 45068

Wheel & Spoke Antique Mall

Huge selection and variety
STORE FORMAT
Multi-Vendor Mall
STORE SIZE
Vast Warehouse
PRICE RANGE
$$
SPECIALTIES
FurnitureCollectiblesDecorative Items

WHAT CUSTOMERS LOVE

  • Always finding unique treasures
  • Improved atmosphere under new ownership
  • Something for everyone

AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT

  • Some vendors have overpriced items
  • Cold/drafty in winter

Housed in a historic factory building, Wheel & Spoke Antique Mall is an enormous treasure trove requiring hours to explore. Customers appreciate the wide aisles with shopping carts available for serious buyers. The mall features hundreds of vendor booths offering everything from furniture and collectibles to vintage items. Recently improved under new ownership, the space is now cleaner, better organized, and more inviting with amenities like free coffee and restrooms.

500 S Meridian St, Portland, IN 47371