Top 10 Antique Stores in Carmel, IN

Jake's Antiques overwhelms visitors with its massive, seemingly endless space filled with countless vendor booths. Plan for a full day as customers routinely spend hours exploring the diverse inventory. The friendly staff and reasonable prices are consistently praised, with furniture, collectibles, and nostalgic items being standouts. Many reviewers mention returning regularly to discover what's new, as inventory constantly changes across the numerous vendor spaces.

Spanning 30,000 sq ft, this enormous antique mall houses a maze of booths with an impressive selection of collectibles, furniture, and primitives. Clean and well-organized, customers regularly spend 2-4 hours exploring the ever-changing inventory. Known for beautifully decorated seasonal displays and friendly staff, it's a treasure hunter's paradise that rewards repeat visits as vendors continually refresh their merchandise.

Housed in a former roller rink, Treasure Mart Antique Mall offers three floors of diverse antiques and collectibles in well-organized booth spaces. Visitors appreciate the clean, spacious layout with everything from vintage glassware and furniture to unique collectibles and primitives. Plan for at least 1-2 hours to explore the labyrinthine aisles, where friendly staff will help unlock cases and assist with purchases. Many vendors offer discounts, creating treasure hunting opportunities for patient browsers.

Housed in a spacious location that surprises visitors with its size, Carmel Old Town Antique Mall features numerous vendor booths offering a diverse selection of collectibles, vintage jewelry, and decorative glassware. Though some visitors find prices on the higher side, the clean, well-organized layout and friendly staff create a pleasant browsing experience that typically takes 1-2 hours to fully explore. The mall's varied inventory keeps collectors returning to discover unique treasures.

Housed in a historic building on Noblesville's square, this three-floor antique mall offers an extensive collection from numerous vendors. Particularly strong in collectibles, vintage items, and furniture, the store rewards patient exploration with everything from vinyl records to military memorabilia. While wheelchair access is limited, the friendly staff are known for their helpfulness. Plan for 1-2 hours to properly explore all levels of this well-organized treasure trove.

Sell It Here is a massive indoor vendor mall featuring hundreds of booths with an overwhelming variety of merchandise. From antiques and collectibles to furniture and home décor, this clean, well-organized space requires several hours to explore thoroughly. Vendors offer everything from budget-friendly vintage furniture popular with college students to unique decorative items. Customers appreciate the constantly changing inventory but should be prepared to wrap their own fragile purchases.

The Scrounge Around offers a clean, well-organized multi-vendor shopping experience with numerous booths featuring vintage treasures, collectibles, and furniture. Shoppers appreciate the spacious layout that makes browsing comfortable, with a furniture barn located in back. Plan to spend 1-2 hours exploring the eclectic mix of antiques, decorative items, and nostalgic pieces. The friendly staff and ever-changing inventory keep customers returning.