Top 10 Antique Stores in Cape May, NJ

Heritage Antiques Market houses multiple vendors in a spacious, well-organized layout that rewards thorough exploration. Visitors appreciate the diverse selection of quality antiques, from furniture and collectibles to decorative pieces at reasonable prices. Plan for 1-2 hours to browse the many booths, each with distinct offerings. The friendly staff and clean, well-lit environment create an inviting atmosphere for both casual browsers and serious collectors.

The Brush Factory on Kings houses over 60 vendors offering an eclectic mix of home goods, furniture, clothing, and art alongside Ray's produce market. Customers frequently spend 1-2 hours exploring the well-organized departments featuring both vintage and modern pieces. The spacious layout allows for comfortable browsing through themed sections, with many reviewers noting the fresh produce and plants as an unexpected highlight.

The Pottery Place is a spacious, eclectic store with multiple rooms and an outdoor area featuring an impressive selection of pottery, garden statues, and unique home decor. Visitors can easily spend hours exploring their extensive collection of planters, coastal-themed items, and artistic pieces. The coffee bar adds to the browsing experience, making this a worthwhile destination for those seeking distinctive decorative items for both indoor and outdoor spaces.

The Spot At The Ave is a two-floor multi-vendor marketplace featuring nearly 80 different dealers with an eclectic mix of vintage items, collectibles, and handcrafted goods. The expansive space includes a crystal shop, record selection, and handmade crafts alongside antiques. Customers regularly mention spending hours exploring both floors, with many noting they couldn't see everything in one visit. Reasonably priced merchandise ranges from vintage furniture to unique gifts.

They're Action Figures is a collector's paradise packed with vintage and modern action figures, Funko Pops, and comics. Owner Walt has created a nostalgic toy store atmosphere with fair prices often beating big box retailers. The well-organized space offers everything from Marvel Legends to Star Wars, WWE figures to rare collectibles. Customers regularly drive from neighboring states for the exceptional selection and knowledgeable, friendly service.

Housed in a repurposed garage, West End Garage offers a diverse shopping experience with dozens of vendor booths selling everything from handcrafted art and jewelry to vintage collectibles. The spacious interior feels larger than it appears from outside, with well-organized stalls showcasing local artisans and antiques. An in-house café offers coffee and baked goods, making it easy to spend a couple hours browsing the eclectic mix of merchandise.

Cape May Antique Center houses 70+ dealer booths offering an eclectic mix of collectibles, jewelry, and vintage furniture. Customers appreciate the well-organized layout that's 'bigger than you think' with new merchandise arriving weekly. From military memorabilia and vinyl records to nautical items and stained glass, browsers typically spend 1-2 hours exploring. The center maintains year-round operation, with prices ranging from affordable trinkets to higher-end antiques.